Hybrid: Experiment
- Exotic Meson Decay to $\omega\pi^{0}\pi^{-}$
M. Lu, et al
hep-ex/0405044
A partial-wave analysis of the mesons from the reaction $\pi^{-}%
p\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{-}\pi^{0}\pi^{0}p$ has been performed. The data show
$b_{1}\pi$ decay of the spin-exotic states $\pi_{1}(1600)$ and \
$\pi_{1}(2000)$. Three isovector $2^{-+}$ states were seen in the
$\omega\rho^{-}$ decay channel. In addition to the well known $\pi_{2}(1670)$,
signals were also observed for $\pi_{2}(1880)$ and $\pi_{2}(1970)$.
- : Exotic Meson Production in the $f_{1}(1285)\pi^{-}$ System observed in
the Reaction $\pi^{-} p \to \eta\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{-} p$ at 18 GeV/c
J. Kuhn, et al
hep-ex/0401004
This letter reports results from the partial wave analysis of the
$\pi^{-}\pi^{-}\pi^{+}\eta$ final state in $\pi^{-}p$ collisions at 18GeV/c.
Strong evidence is observed for production of two mesons with exotic quantum
numbers of spin, parity and charge conjugation, $J^{PC} = 1^{-+}$ in the decay
channel $f_{1}(1285)\pi^{-}$. The mass $M = 1709 \pm 24 \pm 41$ MeV/c^2 and
width $\Gamma = 403 \pm 80 \pm 115$ MeV/c^2 of the first state are consistent
with the parameters of the previously observed $\pi_{1}(1600)$. The second
resonance with mass $M = 2001 \pm 30 \pm 92$ MeV/c^2 and width $\Gamma = 333
\pm 52 \pm 49$ MeV/c^2 agrees very well with predictions from theoretical
models. In addition, the presence of $\pi_{2}(1900)$ is confirmed with mass $M
= 2003 \pm 88 \pm 148$ MeV/c^2 and width $\Gamma = 306 \pm 132 \pm 121$ MeV/c^2
and a new state, $a_{1}(2096)$, is observed with mass $M = 2096 \pm 17 \pm 121$
MeV/c^2 and width $\Gamma = 451 \pm 41 \pm 81$ MeV/c^2. The decay properties of
these last two states are consistent with flux tube model predictions for
hybrid mesons with non-exotic quantum numbers.
- Study of the $\eta\pi$ and $\eta'\pi$ spectra and interpetation of
possible exotic $J^{PC}=1^{-+}$ mesons
Adam P. Szczepaniak, Maciej Swat, Alex R. Dzierba, Scott Teige
hep-ph/0304095
We discuss a coupled channel analysis of the $\eta\pi$ and $\eta'\pi$ systems
produced in $\pi^-p$ interactions at 18 GeV/$c$. We show that known $Q\bar Q$
resonances, together with residual soft meson-meson rescattering, saturate the
spectra including the exotic $J^{PC}=1^{-+}$ channel. A possibility of a narrow
exotic resonance at a mass near 1.6 GeV/$c^2$ cannot, however, be ruled out.
- A Study of the \eta \pi^{0} Spectrum and Search for a J^{PC} = 1^{-+}
Exotic Meson
A. R. Dzierba, J. Gunter, S. Ichiriu, R. Lindenbusch, E. Scott, P.
Smith, M. R. Shepherd, S. Teige, M. ~Swat, A. P. Szczepaniak, S. P. Denisov,
A. V. Popov, D. I. Ryabchikov, L. I. Sarycheva, J. Napolitano
hep-ex/0304002
A partial wave analysis (PWA) of the of the $\eta \pi ^0$ system (where $\eta
\to \gamma \gamma$) produced in the charge exchange reaction $\pi ^-p\to \eta
\pi ^0n$ at an incident momentum of 18 GeV$/c$ is presented as a function of
${\eta \pi ^0}$ invariant mass, $m_{\eta\pi^0}$, and momentum transfer squared,
$t_{\pi^{-}\to\eta\pi}$, from the incident $\pi^-$ to the outgoing ${\eta\pi
^0}$ system.
$S$, $P$ and $D$ waves were included in the PWA. The $a_0(980)$ and
$a_2(1320)$ states are clearly observed in the overall ${\eta\pi ^0}$ effective
mass distribution as well as in the amplitudes associated with $S$ wave and $D$
waves respectively after partial wave decomposition. The observed distributions
in moments (averages of spherical harmonics) were compared to the results from
the PWA and the two are consistent. The distribution in $t_{\pi^{-}\to\eta\pi}$
for individual $D$ waves associated with natural and unnatural parity exchange
in the $t$-channel are consistent with Regge phenomenology. Of particular
interest in this study is the $P$ wave since this leads to an exotic
$J^{PC}=1^{-+}$ for the $\eta \pi$ system. A $P$ wave is present in the data,
however attempts to describe the mass dependence of the amplitude and phase
motion with respect to the $D$ wave as a Breit-Wigner resonance are
problematic. This has implications regarding the existence of a reported exotic
$J^{PC} = 1^{-+}$ meson decaying into $\eta \pi^0$ with a mass near 1.4
GeV$/c^2$.
- Hybrid Meson Production via Ultra-Peripheral Pion Scattering from a
Virtual Photon Target
Murray Moinester
hep-ex/0301023
The CERN COMPASS experiment may use 100-280 GeV pion and Kaon beams and
magnetic spectrometers and calorimeters to measure Hybrid (mixed quark-gluon)
meson production cross sections in the ultra-peripheral Primakoff scattering of
high energy pions and Kaons from virtual photons in the Coulomb field of High-Z
targets. There are strong advantages to study Hybrid mesons by the Primakoff
reactions pi- gamma --> Hybrid --> rho pi, eta pi, eta' pi, pi b1, pi f1; and
similar reactions with a K- beam. Such data should provide significant new
input for a more complete understanding of the strong interactions of QCD. A
brief description and update of this program is presented.
- A study of the reaction pim p --> omega pim p at 18 GeV/c: The D and S
decay amplitudes for b1(1235) --> omega pi
Mina Nozar, et al, for the E852 collaboration
hep-ex/0206026
The reaction pim p --> omega pim p, omega --> pip pim pi0 has been studied at
18 GeV/c. The omega pim mass spectrum is found to be dominated by the b1(1235).
Partial Wave Analysis shows that b1 production is dominated by natural parity
exchange. The S-wave and D-wave amplitudes for b1(1235) --> omega pi have been
determined, and it is found that the amplitude ratio, |D/S| = 0.269 +/-
(0.009)stat +/- (0.01)sys and the phase difference, phi(D-S) = 10.54 deg +/-
(2.4)stat +/- (3.9)sys.
- The JPC=1-+ hunting season at VES
Valery Dorofeev, for VES Collaboration
hep-ex/0110075
We present preliminary results of study of the ethapi-, etha'pi- and b1pi
systems produced in the pi-Be-interaction at 28GeV/c. JPC=2++ and 1-+-waves
resulted from the PWA have been fitted in each system separately to establish
the nature of the 1-+ wave. A hypothesis of the 1-+ wave resonant nature in the
ethapi- and etha'pi- has no statistically significant preference over the
non-resonant one. The b1pi-system study confirms the results of the 37GeV/c
beam data analysis in favor of the resonant treatment of the bump at 1.6GeV.
- QCD Confinement and the Hall D Project at Jefferson Lab
Alex R. Dzierba
hep-ex/0106010
An understanding of the confinement mechanism in QCD requires a detailed
mapping of the spectrum of hybrid mesons. Understanding confinement means
understanding the role of gluons and it is in hybrid mesons that the gluonic
degrees of freedom are manifest. High statistics searches for such states with
pion and p beams have resulted in some tantalizing signals. There is good
reason to expect beams of photons to yield hybrid mesons with J^{PC} quantum
numbers not possible within the conventional picture of mesons as qqbar bound
states. Meager data currently exist on the photoproduction of light quark
mesons. At Jefferson Lab in Newport News, VA plans are underway to upgrade the
energy of the electron accelerator to 12 GeV. Along with this energy upgrade, a
hermetic detector housed in new experimental hall (Hall D) will be used to
collect data on photoproduced mesons with unprecedented statistics. With 12 GeV
electrons, a 9 GeV linearly polarized photon beam will be produced using the
coherent bremsstrahlung technique.
- Observation of exotic meson production in the reaction $ \pi^{-} p \to
\eta^{\prime} \pi^- p$ at 18 GeV/c
E.I. Ivanov, et al
hep-ex/0101058
An amplitude analysis of an exclusive sample of 5765 events from the reaction
$\pi^{-} p \to \eta^{\prime} \pi^- p$ at 18 GeV/c is described. The
$\eta^{\prime} \pi^-$ production is dominated by natural parity exchange and by
three partial waves: those with $J^{PC} = 1^{-+}, 2^{++},$ and $4^{++}$. A
mass-dependent analysis of the partial-wave amplitudes indicates the production
of the $a_2(1320)$ meson as well as the $a_4(2040)$ meson, observed for the
first time decaying to $\eta^{\prime}\pi^-$. The dominant, exotic
(non-$q\bar{q}) $ $1^{-+}$ partial wave is shown to be resonant with a mass of
$1.597 \pm 0.010^{+0.045}_{-0.010}$ GeV/c^2 and a width of $0.340 \pm 0.040 \pm
0.050$ GeV/c^2 . This exotic state, the $\pi_1(1600)$, is produced with a $t$
dependence which is different from that of the $a_2(1320)$ meson, indicating
differences between the production mechanisms for the two states.
- Pion Polarizabilities and Hybrid Meson Structure at CERN COMPASS
Murray Moinester
hep-ex/0012063
CERN COMPASS can investigate pion-photon interactions, to achieve a unique
Primakoff Coulomb physics program, centered on pion polarizability and hybrid
meson structure studies. COMPASS uses 100-280 GeV beams (muon, pion) and a
virtual photon target, and magnetic spectrometers and calorimeters to measure
the complete kinematics of pion-photon reactions. The COMPASS experiment is
scheduled to begin data runs in 2001. Pion polarizabilities and hybrid mesons
can be studied via the Primakoff reactions pion + gamma ---> pion + gamma and
pion + gamma ---> Hybrid. The electric (alpha) and magnetic (beta) pion and
Kaon polarizabilities characterize their deformation in an electromagnetic
field, as occurs during gamma-pion Compton scattering. They depend on the
rigidity of their internal structures as composite particles, and are therefore
important quantities to test the validity of theoretical models. The
polarizability measurement will provide an important new test of QCD chiral
dynamics. The studies of quark-antiquark-gluon hybrid mesons would improve our
understanding of these exotic mesons. COMPASS may improve previous Primakoff
polarizability and Hybrid studies by two to three orders of magnitude.
Appendixes A (Pion and Kaon Polarizabilities at COMPASS) and B (Hybrid Meson
Structure at COMPASS) of this contribution include evaluations submitted to the
APS DNP Town Meeting White Paper Committee. These summarize (1) the fundamental
scientific issues addressed, (2) major achievements since the last DNP long
range plan, (3) the short and long term U.S. outlook, (4) comparison of U.S.
and global effort, (5) other issues.
- Hybrid Meson Structure at COMPASS
Murray Moinester, Suh Urk Chung
hep-ex/0003008
We describe a pion physics program attainable with the CERN COMPASS
spectrometer, involving tracking detectors and an electromagnetic calorimeter.
COMPASS can realize state-of-the-art pion beam hybrid meson and meson radiative
transition studies. We review here the physics motivation for this program. We
describe the beam, detector, trigger requirements, and hardware/software
requirements for this program. The triggers for all this hybrid meson physics
can be implemented for simultaneous data taking.
We will investigate hybrid meson production via pion-photon Primakoff and
pion-Pomeron diffractive interactions. We will determine new properties of
quark-antiquark-gluon hybrid mesons, using unique production methods, to
improve our understanding of these exotic mesons.
The CERN COMPASS experiment uses 100-280 GeV beams (muon, pion), and magnetic
spectrometers and calorimeters, to measure the complete kinematics of
pion-photon and pion-Pomeron reactions. The COMPASS experiment is currently
under construction, and scheduled to begin data runs in 2001. We carry outsimulation studies to optimize the beam, detector, trigger, and
hardware/software for achieving high statistics data with low systematic
uncertainties in the hybrid meson component of this program. We will improve
previous Primakoff Hybrid studies by three orders of magnitude. We implement
special detectors and triggers for hybrid meson production reactions. We
propose to prepare for these COMPASS pion beam hybrid studies by setting up
with muon beam tests.
- Title: Partial Wave Analysis of $J/\psi \to \gamma (K^{\pm}K_S^0\pi^{\mp})$
J.Z. Bai, et al. (BES Collaboration)
hep-ex/0002007
BES data on $J/\psi \to \gamma (K^{\pm} K_S^0 \pi^{\mp})$ are presented.
There is a strong peak due to $\eta(1440)/\iota$, which is fitted with a
Breit-Wigner amplitude with $s$-dependent widths for decays to $K^*K$, $\kappa
K$, $\eta \pi\pi$ and $\rho\rho$; $\kappa$ refers to the $K\pi$ S-wave. At a
$K\bar{K}\pi$ mass of $\sim 2040$ MeV, there is a second peak with width $\sim
400$ MeV; $J^P = 0^-$ is preferred over $1^+$ and $2^-$ respectively by 5.2 and
6.8 standard deviations. It is a possible candidate for a $0^-$ $s\bar sg$
hybrid partner of $\pi(1800)$.
- A proposal on the search for the hybrid with I^G(J^{PC})=1^-(1^{-+}) in
the process $J/\psi\to\rho\omega\pi\pi$ at upgraded BEPC/BES
De-Min Li, Hong Yu, Qi-Xing Shen
hep-ph/0001063
The moment expressions for the boson resonances X with spin-parity
J_X^{P_XC}=0^{++}, 1^{-+}, 1^{++}, and 2^{++} possibly produced in the process
$J/\psi\to\rho X$, $X\to b_1(1235)\pi$, $b_1\to \omega \pi$ are given in terms
of the generalized moment analysis method. The resonance with J_X^{P_XC}=1^{-+}
can be distinguished from other resonances by means of these moments except for
some rather special cases. The suggestion that the search for the hybrid with
I^G(J^{PC})=1^-(1^{-+}) can be performed in the decay channel
$J/\psi\to\rho\omega\pi\pi$ at upgraded BEPC/BES is presented.
- Observation of a New JPC = 1 - + Exotic State in the Reaction pi - p
(right-arrow) pi + pi - pi - p at 18 GeV/c
The E852 Collaboration
Phys.Rev.Lett. 81 (1998) 5760
postscript
A partial-wave analysis of the reaction pi - p(right-arrow) pi + pi - pi - p at 18 GeV/c has been
performed on a data sample of 250 000 events obtained by Brookhaven experiment E852. The
expected JPC = 1 + + a1(1260) , 2 + + a2(1320) , and 2 - + pi 2(1670) resonant states are clearly
observed. The exotic JPC = 1 - + wave produced in the natural parity exchange processes shows
distinct resonancelike phase motion at about 1.6 GeV/c2 in the rho pi channel. A mass-dependent fit
results in a resonance mass of 1593 ± 8[sup +29][sub -47] MeV /c2 and a width of 168 ± 20[sup
+150][sub -12] MeV /c2 .
- Study of the reaction pi- Be --> omega pi- pi0 Be
VES collaboration
hep-ex/9810013
The results of patial wave analysis of the omega pi- pi0 system, produced in the reaction pi- Be --> pi+ 2pi- 2pi0 Be at
beam momentum of 37 GeV are presented. An indication of the resonant type structure with mass near 1.74 GeV and
JpMetha=0-0+ in the omega rho- system was found. The decay branching ratio of a2(1320)- to omega pi- pi0 was
measured. A wave with JpMetha=2+1+ shows a broad bump at M near 1.7 GeV. The decays pi2(1670)- --> omega rho-
and a4(2040)- --> omega rho- were observed for the first time. The bump in the b1(1235)pi wave with exotic quantum
numbers Jpc=1-+ at M near 1.7 GeV was observed.
- Evidence for Exotic Meson Production in the Reaction $ \pi^{-} p \to
\eta \pi^{-} p$ at 18 GeV/c
The E852 Collaboration
hep-ex/9705011
Phys.Rev.Lett. 79 (1997) 1630-1633
The $\eta \pi^{-}$ system has been studied in the reaction $\pi^{-} p \to \eta \pi^{-} p$
at 18 GeV/c. A large asymmetry in the angular distribution is observed indicating
interference between L-even and L-odd partial waves. The $a_{2}(1320)$ is observed in
the $J^{PC}$ = $2^{++}$ wave, as is a broad enhancement between 1.2 and 1.6
GeV/c^{2} in the $J^{PC} = 1^{-+}$ wave. The observed phase difference between these
waves shows that there is phase motion in addition to that due to $a_{2}(1320)$ decay.
The data can be fitted by interference between the $a_{2}(1320)$ and an exotic $1^{-+}$
resonance with $M = (1370 \pm 16 {+50}\atop{-30}$) MeV/c^2 and $\Gamma =(385
\pm 40 {+65}\atop{-105}$) MeV/c^2.
-
THE PHOTOPRODUCTION OF POSSIBLE HYBRID MESONS AT AVERAGE (E GAMMA) =110-GEV.
Kathleen Danyo Blackett (Tennessee U.). UMI-96-09274-mc (microfiche),
Aug 1995. 96pp. Ph.D.Thesis.
-
AN EXPERIMENTAL STUDY OF OZI SUPPRESSION IN THE REACTION
NEGATIVE PION P---> PHI PHI N AND A SEARCH FOR EXOTIC HYBRIDS.
Cynthia E. Landberg (Rensselaer Poly). UMI-96-08448-mc
(microfiche), Aug 1995. 202pp. Ph.D.Thesis.
-
GLUEBALLS AND HYBRIDS: AN EXPERIMENTAL REVIEW.
Antimo Palano (Bari U. & INFN, Bari). INFN-AE-94-25,
Oct 1994. 20pp. High Energy Physics: QCD Workshop 94, Montpellier, France,
7-13 Jul 1994. Published in Nucl.Phys.Proc.Suppl.39BC:287-300,1995
-
SEARCH FOR HYBRIDS.
Crystal Barrel Collaboration (M. Kunze et al.). 1994.
Published in Phys.Atom.Nucl.57:1497-1502,1994
-
PRODUCTION AND IDENTIFICATION OF EXOTIC STATES: GLUEBALLS
AND HYBRIDS IN P ANTI-P COLLISIONS.
By S.S. Gershtein, A.K. Likhoded (Serpukhov, IFVE). IFVE-92-161,
Nov 1992. 16pp. Submitted to LEAP Conf., Sep 14-16, 1992.
-
MESONS, HYBRIDS, AND GLUEBALLS: MESON SPECTROSCOPY AT
SUPERLEAR.
By Stephen Godfrey (Ottawa Carleton Inst. Phys.). OCIP-C-91-8,
Nov 1991. 14pp.
-
GLUEBALLS, HYBRIDS, AND EXOTIC HADRONS. PROCEEDINGS, BNL
WORKSHOP, BROOKHAVEN, UPTON, USA, AUGUST 29-SEPTEMBER 1, 1988.
By S.U. Chung, (ed.) (Brookhaven). 1989. New York, USA:
AIP (1989) 729 p. (AIP conference proceedings, 185). (Particle and fields
series, 36).
-
SEARCH FOR EXOTICS AT HERA.
By Nichol Brummer (Imperial Coll., London). IC-HEP-96-8,
Mar 1996. 9pp. Presented at 10th Les Rencontres de Physique de la Vallee
d'Aoste: Results and Perspectives in Particle Physics, La Thuile, Italy,
3-9 Mar 1996. In *La Thuile 1996, Results and perspectives in particle
physics* 553-562.
-
THE TWO JET ANGULAR DISTRIBUTION PROBING VIRTUAL EXOTICS
AT HADRON COLLIDERS.
By G. Katsilieris (Athens, Tech U. & Democritos Nuclear
Research Center), O. Korakianitis (Athens, Tech U. & Royal Holloway
- Bedford Coll.), S.D.P. Vlassopulos (Athens, Tech. U.). NTUA-38-93, (Received
Jun 1993). 18pp. Published in Z.Phys.C61:91-96,1994
-
EXPERIMENTAL SEARCH FOR EXOTICS: A JET-II EXPERIMENT FOR
SUPERLEAR.
By D.W. Hertzog (Illinois U., Urbana). ILL-NPL-91-018,
Oct 1991. 12pp. Invited talk given at SuperLEAR
Workshop, Zurich, Switzerland, Oct 9-12, 1991.
-
RESONANCE STATES, INCLUDING EXOTICS IN REACTIONS PI+ P
---> N 4 PI+ 2 PI- AT 4.2-GEV/C BEAM MOMENTUM. (In Russian)
By L.Yu. Brovkin, I.L. Kiselevich, V.I. Mikhailichenko,
S.Ya. Nikitin, T.A. Osipova, V.D. Shkarlet, A.V. Shidlovskii (Moscow, ITEP).
ITEP-90-110, Oct 1990. 14pp.
-
SIGNALS FOR HEAVY EXOTICS AT HADRON COLLIDERS AND SUPERCOLLIDERS.
By M. Drees (CERN), X. Tata (Hawaii U.). CERN-TH-5811-90,
Jul 1990. 18pp. Published in Phys.Lett.B252:695-702,1990
-
EXOTICS GROUP SUMMARY REPORT.
By A.M. Litke (UC, Santa Cruz), A.C. Melissinos (Rochester
U.), P.B. Price (UC, Berkeley). SCIPP-87/112, Nov 1987. 36pp. Report given
at Workshop on Experiments, Detectors and Experimental Areas for the Supercollider,
Berkeley, Calif, Jul 7-17, 1987. Published in Berkeley SSC Wkshp.1987:0853
(QCD184:W61:1987)
-
EXPERIMENTAL REVIEW OF LIGHT QUARK SPECTROSCOPY INCLUDING
EXOTICS WITH HADRONIC REACTIONS.
Tsuneaki Tsuru (KEK, Tsukuba). KEK-Preprint-87-56,
Aug 1987. 18pp. To be publ. in Proc. of 2nd Int. Conf. on Hadron Spectroscopy,
Tsukuba, Japan, Apr 16-18, 1987. IN *TSUKUBA 1987, PROCEEDINGS, HADRON
'87* 233-251 AND TSUKUBA KEK - KEK-PREPR.-87-056 (87,REC.OCT.) 18p.