Scalar: Theory
- Problem of Light Scalar Mesons
N.N. Achasov
hep-ph/0410051
The following topics are considered. 1. Confinement, chiral dynamics and
light scalar mesons. 2. $\phi$-meson radiative decays about nature of light
scalar resonances. Arguments in favor of the four-quark model of the $a_0(980)$
and $f_0(980)$ mesons are given.
Mass and Decay Constant of $I=1/2$ Scalar Meson In QCD Sum Rule
Dong-Sheng Du, Jing-Wu Li, Mao-Zhi Yang
hep-ph/0409302
We calculate the mass and decay constant of $I=1/2$ scalar meson based on QCD
sum rule. The $I=1/2$ scalar mesons are composed of $s\bar{q}$ or $q\bar{s}$
($q=u,d$)in quark model, the quantum numbers of spin and orbital angular
momentum are S=1, L=1. We obtain the mass of the ground sate in this channel is
$1.409\pm 0.026$GeV, which is consistent with the mass of $K_{0}^{\ast}(1430)$.
This implies that $K_{0}^{\ast}(1430)$ is the ground state of $s\bar{q}$ or
$q\bar{s}$ with quantum number $J^P=0^+$. We also predict the first higher
resonance of $K_{0}^{\ast}(1430)$ is above 2.09 GeV.
- A new look at scalar mesons
L. Maiani, A. Polosa, F. Piccinini, V. Riquer
hep-ph/0407017
Light scalar mesons are found to fit rather well a diquark-antidiquark
description. The resulting nonet obeys mass formulae which respect, to a good
extent, the OZI rule. OZI allowed strong decays are reasonably reproduced by a
single amplitude describing the switch of a qbar-q pair, which transforms the
state into two colourless pseudoscalar mesons. Predicted heavy states with one
or more quarks replaced by charm or beauty are briefly described; they should
give rise to narrow states with exotic quantum numbers.
- Structures of the $f_0(980)$, $a_0(980)$ mesons and the strong coupling
constants $g_{f_0 K^+ K^-}$, $g_{a_0 K^+ K^-}$ with the light-cone QCD sum
rules
Zhi-Gang Wang, Wei-Min Yang, and Shao-Long Wan
hep-ph/0401046
In this article, we suppose the scalar mesons $f_0(980)$ and $a_0(980)$ have
both strange and non-strange quark-antiquark components and evaluate the strong
coupling constants $g_{f_0 K^+ K^-}$ and $g_{a_0 K^+ K^-}$ with two
interpolating scalar currents respectively within the framework of the
light-cone QCD sum rules approach. Our observation about the large strong
scalar-$KK$ couplings $g_{f_0 K^+ K^-}$ and $g_{a_0 K^+ K^-}$ will support the
hadronic dressing model, furthermore, in spite of the constituent structure
differences between the $f_0(980)$ and $a_0(980)$ mesons, the strange
components have a larger strong coupling constants with the $K^+K^-$ mesons
state than the non-strange ones, $g_{f_0 K^+ K^-}^{\bar{s}s}\approx
\sqrt{2}g_{f_0 K^+ K^-}^{\bar{n}n}$ and $g_{a_0 K^+ K^-}^{\bar{s}s}\approx
\sqrt{2} g_{a_0 K^+ K^-}^{\bar{n}n}$.
- Instantons and Scalar Multiquark States: From Small to Large N_c
Thomas Schaefer
hep-ph/0309158
We study scalar quark-anti-quark and two-quark-two-anti-quark correlation
functions in the instanton liquid model. We show that the instanton liquid
supports a light scalar-isoscalar (sigma) meson, and that this state is
strongly coupled to both $(\bar{q}q)$ and $(\bar{q}q)^2$. The scalar-isovector
$a_0$ meson, on the other hand, is heavy. We also show that these properties
are specific to QCD with three colors. In the large $N_c$ limit the
scalar-isoscalar meson is not light, and it is mainly coupled to $(\bar{q}q)$.
- Light Scalar Mesons in the Improved Ladder Approximation of QCD with
Strong $U_A(1)$ Breaking
hep-ph/0306040
The spectrum and the mixing angle of the light scalar nonet mesons are
studied using the extended Nambu-Jona-Lasinio (NJL) model as well as the
improved ladder approximation (ILA) of QCD with U_A(1) symmetry breaking
interaction. The U_A(1) breaking is represented by the Kobayashi-Maskawa-'t
Hooft (KMT) interaction. The strength of the KMT interaction in the NJL model
is determined so as to reproduce the electromagnetic decays of the \eta meson.
That in the ILA approach is determined so as to reproduce the pseudoscalar
meson spectrum.
In the extended NJL model, we study the qualitative features of the scalar
meson spectrum. In the scalar nonet spectrum, the KMT interaction is found to
give the right ordering of \sigma - a_0 masses and a few hundred MeV mass
difference between the \sigma and a_0 mesons. We also find that the strangeness
content in the \sigma meson is about 15%.
In the ILA approach, we confirm the qualitative features of the results from
the extended NJL. We obtain the mass spectra of the light pseudoscalar nonet
mesons and the \sigma, a_0 mesons which are consistent with current
experimental data. On the other hand, we show that the obtained f_0 and K_0^*
state can not be identified directly with the experimental data. It may suggest
that the f_0(980) and \kappa(700-900) states may not be explained only by the
quark-anti quark state.
We also find that the strangeness content in the \sigma meson is about 5%. We
obtain the result that the U_A(1) breaking interaction reproducing the mass
spectrum of the pseudoscalar meson gives large effects on the scalar meson mass
spectrum.
- Meson resonances, large N_c and chiral symmetry
V. Cirigliano, G. Ecker, H. Neufeld and A. Pich
hep-ph/0305311
We investigate the implications of large N_c and chiral symmetry for the mass
spectra of meson resonances. Unlike for most other mesons, the mass matrix of
the light scalars deviates strongly from its large-N_c limit. We discuss the
possible assignments for the lightest scalar nonet that survives in the
large-N_c limit.
- U_A(1) Breaking Effects on the Light Scalar Meson Spectrum
Kenichi Naito, Makoto Oka, Makoto Takizawa, Toru Umekawa
hep-ph/0305078
Effects of the U_A(1) breaking interaction on the low-lying nonet scalar
mesons are studied using the extended Nambu-Jona-Lasinio model. The strength of
the U_A(1) breaking interaction is determined by the electromagnetic decays of
the eta meson. We find that the U_A(1) breaking interaction gives rise to about
150 MeV mass difference between the sigma and a_0 mesons. We also find that the
strangeness content in the \sigma meson is about 15%. The calculated mass of
the I=1/2 state is about 200 MeV heavier than that of the I=1 state. The order
of these masses is not likely to change within this model.
- Dynamically Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking and Masses of Lightest Nonet
Scalar Mesons as Composite Higgs Bosons
Yuan-Ben Dai and Yue-Liang Wu
hep-ph/0304075
Based on the (approximate) chiral symmetry of QCD Lagrangian and bound state
assumption of effective meson fields due to strong interactions of gluons, a
nonlinearly realized effective chiral Lagrangian for meson fields is resulted
from integrating over the quark fields by using the new finite regularization
method.
As the new method preserves the symmetry principles of the original theory and
meanwhile keeps the finite quadratic term given by a physically meaningful
characteristic energy scale $M_c$, it then leads the effective chiral field
theory to have a dynamically spontaneous symmetry breaking mechanism. The gap
equations are yielded as the minimal conditions of the effective potential in
the effective theory.
The instanton effects are included via the induced interactions discovered by
't Hooft and found to play an important role in obtaining the physical
solutions for the gap equations. The lightest nonet scalar mesons
($\sigma$, $f_0$, $a_0$ and $\kappa$) appearing as the chiral partners of the
nonet pseudoscalar mesons are found to be as the composite Higgs bosons with
masses below the characteristic energy scale $M_c \sim 1.2$ GeV. In particular,
the mass of the singlet scalar (or the $\sigma$) is found to be $m_{\sigma}
\simeq 688$ MeV.
- Scalar mesons and the muon anomaly
Stephan Narison
hep-ph/0303004
We evaluate systematically some contributions of the QCD scalar mesons,
including radiative decay-productions, not considered with a better attention
until now in the evaluation of the hadronic contributions to the muon anomaly.
The sum of the scalar contributions to be added to the existing Standard Model
predictions a_mu^SM are estimated to be a^S_mu= 11.75(8.25)x10^-10, where the
errors are dominated by the ones from the experimental widths of these scalar
mesons. This result suggests that the value of a_mu^SM and its errors might
have been underestimated in previous works. The inclusion of these new effects
leads to a perfect agreement (0.1 sigma) of the measured value a^exp_mu and
a_mu^SM from tau-decay and implies a 1.7 sigma discrepancy between a^exp_mu and
a_mu^SM from e^+e^- --> hadrons data. More refined unbiased theoretical
estimates require improved measurements of the scalar meson masses and widths.
The impact of our results to a_mu^SM is summarized in the conclusions.
- Isosinglet Scalar Mesons Below 2 GeV and the Scalar Glueball Mass
Amir H. Fariborz
hep-ph/0302133
A collective treatment of the I=0 scalar mesons below 2 GeV [sigma (550),
f0(980), f0(1370), f0(1500) and f0(1710)] in a non-linear chiral Lagrangian
framework that is constrained by the mass and the partial decay widths of the
I=1/2,1 scalars [kappa(900), K0*(1430), a0(980) and a0(1450)] is presented. The
sub-structure of these states in terms of two and four quark components, as
well as a glueball component is explored, and its correlation with the mass of
f0(1370) is studied. Consistency with the available experimental data suggests
that the sigma(550) is dominantly a non-strange four-quark state, whereas the
sub-structure of other I=0 states are sensitive to the input mass of f0(1370).
This investigation estimates the scalar glueball mass in the range 1.49--1.64
GeV.
- Scalar mesons in QCD and tests of the gluon content of the sigma
Stephan Narison
hep-ph/0208081
We summarize the different features of the scalar mesons from QCD spectral
sum rule analyses of the two- and three-point functions. The results do not
favour the u-bar u + d-bar d interpretation of the broad and low mass sigma
(0.6), and the u-bar s resonance nature of the eventually observed kappa(0.9)
meson. We also discuss some OZI-violating and classic semileptonic and
radiative decay processes which can reveal in a model-independent way the
eventual gluon component sigma_B of the sigma. In a meson-gluonium mixing
scenario, one also expects an observation of the K K-bar final states from the
sigma_B which may compete (if phase space allowed) with the one from a low mass
s-bar s state assumed in the literature to be the SU(3) partner of the $\sigma
(0.6)$ if this latter is a u-bar u + d-bar d state
- The Lightest Scalar Nonet as Higgs Bosons of Strong Interactions
Nils A. Tornqvist
hep-ph/0204215
I discuss how an extra light scalar meson multiplet could be understood as an
effective Higgs nonet of a hidden local U(3) symmetry. There is growing
evidence that low energy data requires in addition to a conventional (q bar q)
nonet near 1.4 GeV, another light scalar nonet-like structure below 1 GeV,
(sigma(600), a_0(980), f_0(980), kappa), which could be interpreted as such a
Higgs nonet.
- Scalar mesons above and below 1 GeV
Frank E. Close and Nils A. Tornqvist
hep-ph/0204205
We show that two nonets and a glueball provide a consistent description of
data on scalar mesons below 1.7 GeV. Above 1 GeV the states form a conventional
(q bar q) nonet mixed with the glueball of lattice QCD. Below
1 GeV the states also form a nonet, as implied by the attractive forces of
QCD, but of more complicated nature. Near the center they are 4 quark states of
the Jaffe type in S-wave, with some (q bar q) in P-wave, but further out they
rearrange in colour to two colourless (q bar q) pairs and finally as
meson-meson states. A simple effective chiral model for such a system with two
scalar nonets can be made involving two coupled linear sigma models. One of
these could be looked upon as the Higgs sector of nonpertubative QCD.\
- Simultaneous Softening of sigma and rho Mesons associated with Chiral
Restoration
K. Yokokawa, T. Hatsuda, A.
Hayashigaki, T. Kunihiro
hep-ph/0204163
Complex poles of the unitarized pi-pi scattering amplitude in nuclear matter
are studied. Partial restoration of chiral symmetry is modeled by the decrease
of in-medium pion decay constant f*_{pi}.
For large chiral restoration (f*_{pi}/f_{pi} << 1),
2nd sheet poles in the scalar (sigma) and the vector (rho) mesons are both
dictated by the Lambert W function and show universal softening as f*_{pi}
decreases.
In-medium pi-pi cross section receives substantial contribution from the soft
mode and exhibits a large enhancement in low-energy region.
Fate of this universality for small chiral restoration (f*_{pi}/f_{pi} ~ 1)
is also discussed.
- Scalar Mesons and Chiral Dynamics
Mauro Napsuciale
hep-ph/0204170
We discuss scalar mesons properties on the light of chiral dynamics.
Considering them as the chiral partners of pseudo-scalar mesons we propose an
explanation to their unusual properties based on non-trivial vacuum effects
coming from the interplay between spontaneous breaking of chiral symmetry and
the violation of $U_A(1)$ symmetry by instantons. Including vector mesons as
external sources we work out predictions for radiative decays of vector mesons
and compare some of them with recent experimental results from high luminosity
$\Phi$ factories.
- Title: $U_A(1)$ Symmetry Breaking and the Scalar Sector of QCD
Mauro Napsuciale and Simon Rodriguez
hep-ph/0204149
It is shown that most of the unusual properties of the lowest lying scalar
(and pseudoscalar) mesons can be understood, at the qualitative and
quantitative level, on the basis of the breakdown of the $U_A(1)$ symmetry
coupled to the vacuum expectation values of scalars by the spontaneous breaking
of chiral symmetry.
- Remarks on the f_0(400-1200) scalar meson as the dynamically generated
chiral partner of the pion
Eef van Beveren, Frieder Kleefeld, George Rupp, and Michael D. Scadron
hep-ph/0204139
The quark-level linear sigma model is revisited, in particular concerning the
identification of the f_0(400-1200) (or \sigma(600)) scalar meson as the chiral
partner of the pion. We demonstrate the predictive power of the linear sigma
model through the pi-pi and pi-N s-wave scattering lengths, as well as several
electromagnetic, weak, and strong decays of pseudoscalar and vector mesons. The
ease with which the data for these observables are reproduced in the linear
sigma model lends credit to the necessity to include the sigma as a fundamental
q\bar{q} degree of freedom, to be contrasted with approaches like chiral
perturbation theory or the confining NJL model of Shakin and Wang.
- Dynamical Generation of Scalar Mesons
M. Boglione and M.R. Pennington
hep-ph/0203149
Starting with just one bare seed for each member of a scalar nonet, we
investigate when it is possible to generate more than one hadronic state for
each set of quantum numbers. In the framework of a simple model, we find that
in the I=1 sector it is possible to generate two physical states with the right
features to be identified with the a_0(980) and the a_0(1450). In the I=1/2
sector, we can generate a number of physical states with masses higher than 1
GeV, including one with the right features to be associated with the
K_0^*(1470), but none which can be identified with the light kappa scalar
meson. The I=0 sector is the most complicated and elusive: since all outcomes
are very strongly model dependent, we cannot draw any robust conclusion.
Nevertheless, we find that in that case too, depending on the coupling scheme
adopted, the occurrence of numerous states can be achieved. This shows that
dynamical generation of physical states is a possible solution to the problem
of accounting for more scalar mesons than can fit in a single nonet, as
experiments clearly deliver.
- QCD Finite Energy Sum Rules and the Isoscalar Scalar Mesons
S.N. Cherry and M.R. Pennington
hep-ph/0111158
We apply QCD Finite Energy Sum Rules to the scalar-isoscalar current to
determine the lightest $u \bar{u} + d \bar{d}$ meson in this channel. We use
`pinch-weights' to improve the reliability of the QCD predictions and reduce
the sensitivity to the cut-off $s_0$. A decaying exponential is included in the
weight function to allow us to focus on the contribution from low mass states
to the phenomenological integral. On the theoretical side we include OPE
contributions up to dimension six and a contribution due to instantons taken
from the Instanton Liquid Model. Phenomenologically, we incorporate
experimental data by using a coupling scheme for the scalar current which links
the vacuum polarisation to the $\pi \pi$ scattering amplitude via the scalar
form factor. We find that the sum rules are well saturated for certain
instanton parameters. We conclude that the $f_0(400-1200)$ definitely contains
a large $u \bar{u} + d \bar{d}$ component, whereas the $f_0(980)$ most likely
does not. We are able to estimate the average light quark mass and find
$m_q(1 \GeV) = 5.2 \pm 0.6$ MeV.
- Modified Breit-Wigner formula for mesonic resonances describing OZI
decays of confined $q\bar{q}$ states and the light scalar mesons
Eef van Beveren, George Rupp
hep-ex/0106077
A model-independent expression resembling Breit-Wigner formulae is derived
for the description of resonances which appear in meson-meson scattering.
Starting point is a unitarised meson model, but reduced to a simpler form and
freed from the specific assumption about the confining force. The parameters of
the resulting ``Resonance-Spectrum Expansion'' are directly related to the
confinement spectrum and the mechanism of $^3P_0$ valence-quark-pair creation
for OZI-allowed hadronic decay, and not to the central positions and widths of
resonances. The method also provides a straightforward explanation for the
origin of the light scalar mesons without requiring extra degrees of freedom.
- Scalar Mesons in QCD
Stephan Narison
hep-ph/0012235
We review the analysis of the quark and gluon substructures of the scalar
mesons from QCD spectral sum rules and some low-energy theorems applied to the
scalar QCD anomaly current. The present data favour equal components of \bar
uu+ \bar dd and of gg in the wave functions of the low-mass (below 1 GeV)
scalar mesons, which make the wide \sigma and the narrow f_0(980) as \eta'-like
particles, which can have strong couplings to meson pairs through OZI
violations. A coherent picture of the other I=0 scalar mesons spectra within
this mixing scheme is shortly discussed. We also expect the a_0(980) to be the
lowest isovector \bar ud state, and the K^*_0(1430) its \bar ds partner.
- Molecular status of non-qq mesons
S.M. Gerasyuta, V.I. Kochkin
hep-ph/0011157
The relativistic four-quark equations are found in the framework of the
dispersion relation technique. The calculations of non-qq meson amplitudes
estimate the contributions of three subamplitudes: four-quark amplitude,
glueball amplitude and hadronic molekule amplitudes.
- On the Quark and Gluon Substructure of the Sigma and other Scalar Mesons
Stephan Narison
hep-ph/0009108
Within the increasing experimental evidence of the existence of the I=0
scalar low mass and wide \sigma meson, we review the {\it first} analysis of
its quark and gluon substructure from QCD spectral sum rules and some
low-energy theorems. The present data favour equal components of \bar uu+ \bar
dd and of gg in its wave function, which make the wide sigma and the narrow
f_0(980) as \eta'-like particles. A coherent picture of the other I=0 scalar
mesons spectra within this mixing scheme is shortly discussed. We also expect
the a_0(980) to be the lowest isovector \bar ud state, and the K^*_0(1430) its
\bar ds partner.
- On the Quark and Gluon Substructure of the Sigma and other Scalar Mesons
Stephan Narison
hep-ph/0009108
Within the increasing experimental evidence of the existence of the I=0
scalar low mass and wide \sigma meson, we review the {\it first} analysis of
its quark and gluon substructure from QCD spectral sum rules and some
low-energy theorems. The present data favour equal components of \bar uu+ \bar
dd and of gg in its wave function, which make the wide sigma and the narrow
f_0(980) as \eta'-like particles. A coherent picture of the other I=0 scalar
mesons spectra within this mixing scheme is shortly discussed. We also expect
the a_0(980) to be the lowest isovector \bar ud state, and the K^*_0(1430) its
\bar ds partner.
- The structure of the light scalar mesons and QCD sum rules
V.E. Markushin
hep-ph/0008096
The structure of the light scalar mesons is elucidated by the investigation
of the S-matrix poles and the q-qbar spectral density in a coupled channel
model that includes pi-pi, K-Kbar and q-qbar channels. It is shown that the
dynamical origin of the sigma and f0(980) mesons is consistent with the
observed spectrum of the scalar states. The K-Kbar molecular picture of the
f0(980) is in good agreement with recent experimental data on the decay phi -
gamma pi pi from Novosibirsk.
- sigma and diquark states at finite T and \mu
Yasuo Umino and Vicente Vento
hep-ph/0007210
We calculate the masses, widths and coupling constants of \sigma and color
\bar{3} scalar diquark states at finite temperature (T) and chemical potential
(\mu) using the effective instanton induced `t Hooft interaction Lagrangian and
the N-quantum approach to quantum field theory. These results are then used to
construct a non-perturbative solution to the `t Hooft model beyond the mean
field approximation valid for any T and \mu both in the Nambu-Goldstone and in
the Breit-Wigner phases of the model. We find two branches of the diquark state
for non-zero \mu due to the unequal treatment of particles and anti-particles
at finite density.
- Four-quark state in QCD
Ailin Zhang
hep-ph/0004261
The spectra of some 0++ four-quark states, which are composed of \bar qq
pairs, are calculated in QCD. The light four-quark states are calculated using
the traditional sum rules while four-quark states containing one heavy quark
are computed in HQET. For constructing the interpolating currents, different
couplings of the color and spin inside the \bar qq pair are taken into account.
It is found that the spin and color combination has little effect on the mass
of the four-quark states.
- Quark induced excitations of the instanton liquid
S.V. Molodtsov, A.M. Snigirev, G.M. Zinovjev
hep-ph/0004212
We suggest a mechanism of current quark mass generation which is easily
understandable by calculating the corresponding functional integral in the
tadpole approximation within the instanton liquid model. Quark condensate
excitations influenced by the phononlike modes are analyzed and the
Gell-Mann-Oakes-Renner relation with realistic pion mass is obtained. The
picture of $\sigma$-meson as being mixed with the soft scalar glueball-like
excitation is discussed.
- Scalar Mesons and Glueballs in a Chiral U(3)xU(3) Quark Model with 't
Hooft Interaction
M. Nagy, M. K. Volkov, V. L. Yudichev
hep-ph/0003200
In a U(3)x U(3) quark chiral model of the Nambu-Jona-Lasinio type with the 't
Hooft interaction, the ground scalar isoscalar mesons and a scalar glueball are
described. The glueball (dilaton) is introduced into the effective meson
Lagrangian written in a chirally symmetric form on the base of scale
invariance. The singlet-octet mixing of scalar isoscalar mesons and their
mixing with the glueball are taken into account. Mass spectra of the scalar
mesons and glueball and their strong decays are described.
- The low-mass sigma-meson: Is it an eyewitness of confinement?
V. V. Anisovich and V. A. Nikonov
hep-ph/9911512
In the framework of the dispersion relation N/D-method we restore the
low-energy pi-pi (IJ^{PC}=00^{++})-wave amplitude sewing it with the previously
obtained K-matrix solution for the region 450--1900 MeV [V.V. Anisovich, Yu.D.
Prokoshkin and A.V. Sarantsev, Phys. Lett. B389, 388 (1996)]. The restored
N/D-amplitude has a pole on the second sheet of the complex-s plane, near the
pi-pi threshold. We discuss the hypothesis that this low-mass pole, or the
low-mass sigma-meson, corresponds to the dynamical state related to the
confinement forces, that is the eyewitness of confinement.
- Light Scalar Mesons
Deirdre Black, Amir H. Fariborz, Joseph Schechter
hep-ph/9911387
We review how a certain effective chiral Lagrangian approach to pi pi
scattering, pi K scattering and eta-prime decay to eta pi pi provides evidence
for the existence of light scalars sigma(550) and kappa(900) as well as
describing the f0(980) and the a0(980). An attempt to fit these into a nonet
suggests that their structure is closer to a dual quark-dual antiquark than to
a quark-antiquark. A possible mechanism to explain the next higher mass scalar
nonet is also proposed.
- The light scalars and the broad sigma(500) in the U3xU3 linear sigma
model
Nils A. Tornqvist
hep-ph/9910443
The lightest scalar and pseudoscalar nonets are discussed within the [A
framework of the broken old UxU3 linear sigma model, and it is shown that
already at the tree level this model works remarkably well predicting scalar
masses and couplings not far from present experimental values, when all
parameters are fixed from the pseudoscalar masses and decay constants. The
linear sigma model is the simplest way to implement chiral symmetry together
with the broken SU3 of the quark model, and this, not well known, success in
understanding experiment is comparable to that of the naive quark model for the
heavier multiplets. It is argued that this strongly suggest that the light and
very broad sigma resonance exists near 500 MeV.
- Hoelder Inequalities and Isospin Splitting of the Quark Scalar Mesons
Fang Shi, T.G. Steele, V.Elias, K.B. Sprague, Ying Xue, A.H. Fariborz
hep-ph/9909475
A Hoelder inequality analysis of the QCD Laplace sum-rule which probes the
non-strange (n\bar n) components of the I={0,1} (light-quark) scalar mesons
supports the methodological consistency of an effective continuum contribution
from instanton effects. This revised formulation enhances the magnitude of the
instanton contributions which split the degeneracy between the I=0 and I=1
channels. Despite this enhanced isospin splitting effect, analysis of the
Laplace and finite-energy sum-rules seems to preclude identification of
a_0(980) and a light broad sigma-resonance state as the lightest isovector and
isoscalar spin-zero $n\bar n$ mesons. This apparent decoupling of sigma [\equiv
f_0(400-1200)] and a_0(980) from the quark n\bar n scalar currents suggests
either a non-q \bar q or a dominantly s\bar s interpretation of these
resonances, and further suggests the possible identification of the f_0(980)
and a_0(1450) as the lightest I={0,1} scalar mesons containing a substantial
n\bar n component.
- QCD Sum-Rule Invisibility of the sigma Meson
T.G. Steele, Fang Shi, V. Elias
hep-ph/9905303
QCD Laplace sum-rules for light-quark I=0,1 scalar currents are used to
investigate candidates for the lightest $q\bar q$ scalar mesons. The
theoretical predictions for the sum-rules include instanton contributions which
split the degeneracy between the I=0 and I=1 channels. The self-consistency of
the theoretical predictions is verified through a H\"older inequality analysis,
confirming the existence of an effective instanton contribution to the
continuum. The sum-rule analysis indicates that the f_0(980) and a_0(1450)
should be interpreted as the lightest $q\bar q$ scalar mesons. This apparent
decoupling of the f_0(400-1200) (or $\sigma$) and a_0(980) from the quark
scalar currents suggests a non-$q\bar q$ interpretation of these resonances.